EPREVAEngineer Paper
ENERGYAnalysisMaterialsFluidsEnergy

Edinburgh and Michelin test flexible rubber tidal turbine blades

A 1.26-metre model turbine with rubber blades matched pitch-controlled energy output and cut rapid load fluctuations by up to 29 %, according to a Nature study.

model tidal turbine with flexible rubber blades, visible bending/flattening of the blade trailing edge in the current, internal steel spar running root to tip, underwater test tank setting with submerged cameras
AI-generated image

What the researchers built

Engineers from the University of Edinburgh and Michelin have designed and tested at experimental scale a tidal turbine blade that changes shape by itself in strong currents. The work is published in the journal Nature.

The blades are made of flexible rubber with a stiff internal steel spar running from root to tip. As the current strengthens, the trailing edge bends and flattens the blade's curved profile, shedding excess load without hinges, bearings or actuators, the researchers report.

The team says the design takes inspiration from nature, where fish and trees bend to cope with strong water and wind flows.

Why pitch control is the target

The largest tidal turbines rely on a system of motors, sensors and bearings, known as pitch control, that twists blades away from the flow when currents become too strong. According to the study, these systems are expensive, difficult to maintain underwater and a major source of breakdowns.

Fast-flowing tidal channels are among the harshest places on Earth to build a machine, the researchers write. Turbulence, waves and shifting currents batter turbine blades with constantly fluctuating forces, causing fatigue, shortening lifespans and leading to costly unplanned downtime.

The team says the flexible approach could ultimately eliminate the costliest and most failure-prone parts of tidal turbines.

How the model was tested

The team tested a 1.26-metre model turbine at the University of Edinburgh's FloWave Ocean Energy Research Facility, a 25-metre circular tank that recreates the turbulence found at real tidal energy sites. Cameras submerged in the tank filmed the blades changing shape as they spun.

Combining their measurements with simulations of a full tidal cycle, the researchers found that the rubber-bladed turbine produced the same amount of energy as a conventional turbine with active pitch control under the same conditions.

At the same time, the flexible blades reduced the rapid load fluctuations that drive fatigue damage, which pitch control systems struggle to respond to, by up to 29 %, according to the study. The paper's abstract describes the reduction as up to one-third. Because rubber has a similar density to water, the blades can be made neutrally buoyant, further limiting load fluctuations, the team says.

What the simulations suggest

Computer simulations of a 20-metre turbine suggest that the blades could be similarly effective at commercial scale. Early calculations suggest full-size rubber blades could potentially exceed the 20-year service life expected of current turbines, the team says.

The new design could, if successfully validated at a larger scale, enable the construction of lighter blades and support structures, more powerful generators and cheaper maintenance, all of which would reduce the cost of tidal electricity, according to the researchers.

Limits and context

The work remains at the research stage, and further development and testing would be required before any potential industrial application or commercialisation, the team says. The model tests and simulations have not validated commercial-scale performance or durability.

Michelin has filed a patent on the technology, and the university holds related patents.

According to the press release, the U.K. aims to install 1 gigawatt of tidal stream capacity by 2035, enough to power around 1 million homes, and international projections estimate that more than 300 gigawatts could be generated by tidal power worldwide by 2050. The team notes that tidal energy, unlike wind and solar, can be predicted years in advance.

What the team says

Professor Ignazio Maria Viola of the University of Edinburgh's School of Engineering, who co-led the study, said the sea is so unforgiving that turbines have needed complex machinery just to survive it. "Our blades do that job on their own," he said.

Dr Zhehong Zhang, co-first author of the study, said the idea is to let the blades adapt to the flow rather than relying on complex mechanical systems to withstand harsh ocean currents.

Bertrand Daval, vice president of research and development for composite solutions at Michelin, who co-led the study, said Michelin's expertise lies in understanding how rubber performs under heavy, repeated loads in demanding environments.

Technical fact box

  • Model turbine diameter tested: 1.26 metres
  • Test facility tank: 25-metre circular tank at FloWave
  • Reduction in rapid load fluctuations: up to 29 % (abstract: up to one-third)
  • Energy yield: equivalent to rigid blades with active pitch control over simulated tidal cycles
  • Blade construction: flexible rubber with stiff internal steel spar from root to tip
  • Simulated commercial turbine size: 20 metres
  • Expected service life of current turbines: 20 years
  • U.K. tidal stream target: 1 gigawatt by 2035

Sources

  1. Flexible rubber blades for tidal turbines — Nature — Zhehong Zhang, Junchen Tan, Eric-Carin Neba et al.
  2. Shape-shifting rubber blades could make tidal power cheaper — Phys.org (Technology)

Discussion

Technical questions and corrections are welcome. Comments are signed and checked before they appear.

No comments yet.

Sign in to add a typed review comment. Reviews are signed with your name.

More analysis